A/N: I'm starting this because I have betad quite a few stories and when I hang out on Shiro's Gaming Omniverse, - discord .gg/wd3tUYWVCd - I often see questions about similar topics. Often knowing more about these topics can help you grow as a writer, and in my humble opinion, I have a pretty decent grasp of the English language. So here are some of the questions that I have answered, in the format of a guide to writing, may it guide you well.
Chapter 7: Managing ideas and community feedback
Ideas
Ideas are crazy in their number and scope, while writing your fic you will receive hundreds of ideas or requests from reviews and your own brain, way too many to implement. In a previous chapter I discussed how to navigate your way around writer's block, but an influx of Ideas can be equally as bad. Trying to implement too many cool ideas is a problem and sorting through ideas should be a two step process.
Step 1: Does the idea actually make sense?
At first glance tons of ideas can look like they must be sick and need to be implemented immediately, but often the coolest ideas are just cool at first look, upong further inspection they are actually dumb and would make a huge mockery of everything else that happens.
Step 2: Does the idea work in your fic?
Even if the idea is theoretically feasible, it might not work in your fic. Remember that everything new that you put into your fic must jive with everything you have already written. This means that if you have already given an expected power scale, you cannot introduce something to throw that out of whack. If you have fleshed your characters out in a way that would lead them to certain decisions, just throwing that out the window for shits and giggles, or the "better idea" is a BIG no no. You should keep to the central ideas of your fic and any idea that strays from that should be thrown out the window or shelved for a later fic.
Step 3: Is it necessary?
This may sound like a superficial question at first, but really think about it. Is this idea necessary? As I have previously noted, and will likely note again, simplicity is the heart of any good fic. As a fic gets more complicated it gets exponentially harder to write, ideas need to be balanced against every single other idea in the fic, each new element must work with every single element that has already been used. Straying from this idea will lead to your fic becoming a huge jumbly mess, you will hate it, all but the people who recommended the ideas will hate it, and people will stop reading. You might even stop writing it. So keep your fic simple, keep the ideas manageable, go through with a max of one crazy idea per fic and make sure you thoroughly work through it before even entertaining the idea of another one.
If an idea looks good and yet doesn't pass muster for this fic, or even for the fic as it is, but might be useful later, write it down. Keeping copious notes is the perfect way to keep yourself organized and your thoughts cohesive. Not remembering an idea that you once had is the worst, so do yourself a favor and just write it down.
Feedback
Feedback is a huge two faced sword, on the one hand it can be amazing, fun comments that give you great ideas, help point out problems in your fic, and generally make you feel all warm and fuzzy inside. On the other hand reviews can be scathing, insulting you and your fic, nasty words that would hurt anyone to the bone.
For hate reviews just remember, fuck them, they didnt have to read your fic, they read it, and then decided that the free content that you so nicely made an
option for them was worth being a complete fucking tool and sending you a hate review. Its hard but you have to ignore those dicks,
especially guest reviewers (if it applies). The SGO server is filled with guest reviews, posted for the amusement of all, these are hateful dickwads that are usually so dumb it beggars the mind, people so unbelivably naive and lacking in common sense that receiving one of these reviews should be more a badge of honor than it is something to be sad about.
For Critical reviews, its criticism is usually intended to help you. Read it, think about it, and if, after much consideration, you feel that not only do they have a point, but it is a good one, alter your fic to match if you feel it appropriate. At the end of the day it is
your fic not theirs and you should write it the way you feel you want to. It might not become the best fic or the most viewed fic, but you should write what you want to write, you aren't getting paid, the only thing you get out of it is your own enjoyment of watching the fic become what you wanted it to be. Even if the idea is amazing and way better than your own, if you feel like it would take away from your enjoyment of your own fic, don't use it.
For mistake correction, it's just a mistake. Take heart in the fact that people like your fic enough to point out small mistakes or huge errors. Fic breaking problems can crop up and can almost always be written around. If you have followed my guide up until this point (specifically ch6, how to start a fic) it is unlikely that you will actually find anything that is truly gamebreaking. If you didn't know enough about the universe to learn that one obscure fic breaking power. FUCKING IGNORE IT you aint perfect, if you dont write it into the fic then there is no reason for it to break the fic. Your fic is an Alternate Universe, whatever you want to exist there exists, and what you don't want to exist just isn't written in. You can address those problems with an AN that simply says "hey thanks for pointing that out but that doesnt exist in this fic bc i said so" or "To those that mentioned X super mega OP breaker power, no fucking way that shit exists in this universe/timeline/whatever your fic is." Just because something exists doesn't mean it has to be used.
When it comes down to it. This is your fic, write what you will and don't write what you won't, the ideas you use are up to you, this is merely a guide to help your fic be as good as it can be.
Happy writing, You can find me on SGO if you want to ask me any questions
Thank you to Mand'alor from the SGO server for helping me round out my ideas.