Ack
(Verified Ratbag) (Unverified Great Old One)
- Joined
- Feb 12, 2014
- Messages
- 7,479
- Likes received
- 78,151
Your post came across as though you were accusing me of literally making up those thread-posts on my own and having my own back-and-forth conversations using the various PHO readers as mouthpieces.That's a very long way of saying, "Yes, I agree with you. I knew what I was doing, knew it wasn't ideal, and chose to do it anyway." I never once asked you to change your story. I simply told you that I didn't like that part of it and why, which is part of the function of forum pages like this one.
But I think that trying to blame readers for it is in poor taste. If a reader tells you to put XYZ into your story and you don't agree, I imagine you, like most if not all authors, can, will, and do ignore them or tell them to get stuffed. Like you did here to me because you thought I was telling you to change something, which, again, I wasn't. Just because readers post something is not a reason to include it, and as it's your story, completely under your control, pointing at them and saying "It's their fault" when someone complains is cheesy. You're the author. You decide what does and doesn't go into your story, as you so vehemently pointed out in this very post, and therefore YOU are the one responsible, not the readers. You can (and should) credit them when someone likes something you included, but blaming them when someone doesn't is not how it works. Yet twice on this topic alone that's precisely what you did.
That's all I have to say on this topic, because as someone said it's getting repetitive.
I wasn't blaming the readers for submitting those posts. I was crediting them with it.
They, the readers of this fic, enjoyed seeing their words canonised. I enjoyed giving them the chance to have that happen.
I never said anything about knowing how I've done something 'wrong' with this fic. Having such a long PHO segment was pushing the boundaries, but it's not actually wrong. Just because you, personally didn't enjoy it, and some others found it a little tedious, did not make it wrong.
This is a learning process; A Darker Path is the first fic I've done with semi-regular PHO segments, and I'm still working out what most people like and what they don't. I recognised that such a long segment wasn't to everyone's taste, and acknowledged this, but (and this is important) it wasn't wrong. This is a free story, that I'm writing for free and you're reading for free, so I can experiment and see what works better than other stuff, which also means that if I do something that some readers aren't thrilled about but others love, it doesn't mean it's wrong.
It's just different.
You not liking it doesn't make it wrong. It just means you don't like it.
That said, I will be reining in the PHO post lengths from now on, but because I want to. Not because it's wrong.
Got it? Got it.
Good.