Sorry for the lateness of the response - I live on GMT so I've only just got round to my morning check of forums I follow. I'm sorry if I came across as hostile - I just wanted to get across the few minor niggles I had with an otherwise great story. M'apologies if I went too far.
Umm... they did? I don't recall them being surprised by the announcement, and as it was a Taylor interlude, and Taylor was all "holy shit, we won and ruined Piggot in order to replace her with our puppet", I'd say she was quite aware of who Calvert was.
Now, as only a handful of people in Pantheon know who Coil was- and they're all the upper leadership- the rest of the group wouldn't have any context of this- but Taylor certainly knew, as did Lisa, Amelia, and Riley.
No one else does, of course.
It's been a while since I've read the chapter in question but I recall the dialogue running something as follows: 'Some guy named Calvert's director now,' 'Huh,' I guess it's possible they knew it was Coil, but it wasn't very clearly indicated.
Why would he need a 'ping' to get that feature. Summoning matter out of nowhere is what his shard does. His power is summoning matter out of nowhere.
Because 'exists in every dimension' is kinda a special quality? I mean, I guess you can say that it was an upgrade of the Kaiser bud he has, but it doesn't seem to fit with his canon shard's limitations (Golem may be pretty broken if you know how to use him right, but he's not 'lolno Sting' broken).
He was captured and turned over to Dragon. I'm sure this is mentioned. Something about her being the only one with gear that they were sure would contain him, and being ready to kill him if he broke free BEFORE he was contained... I know this was covered...
Misread - thought it was only Leet that Dragon got her claws on. Still, would've liked their to be a scene with Taylor2 freaking out.
... Umm... that was a significant plot point...
As I said above, I didn't quite myself clear with this one - I meant more
what will Taylor do now - try again after a discussion with Amy or discard the whole plan or...
It's clear Lisa's working out a perfect approach plan, and since they haven't done it yet, it's equally clear they haven't found one.
Fair nuff - still think it probably needs to be resolved at some point.
I don't see how that's really a "plot point" to juggle, but you'll find out when they show them off in combat.
Again, fair nuff. Hope to see em soon.
Will likely never be seen in the story. As made clear in the omake.
Ugh, speedreading omake kicks me in the ass again. Thanks for clarifying.
Part of their problem is they have no plans for Scion. He's unbeatable and they don't know how to fix that. They occasionally mention thoughts in several chapters to this effect. They have no answers.
Then they should try and begin piecing something together at some point, even if it's as dumb as Cauldron's 'suddenly army'.
The whole 'We're part of Pantheon but not part and we disapprove of about 75% of their actions but are absolutely crucial for Endbringer fights' thing. Again, I should have made it clearer. Also, I do feel they act a bit irrational in this story - again, a small flaw in an otherwise spotless dish.
I hope you don't take any of this as an attack - it's simply me trying to do what you ask your readers for: point out the bits that don't work for them and suggest improvements. I'm sorry if I came across as hostile.