Something wrong with the multiquotes on this site.
Okay, I have issues with this as a 'reason Taylor can't have her brain altered so that she can give Amy sweet lesbian love.'.
First one is, when Taylor first had this done, Amy didn't have that reaction at all. I can't say for certain (because I can't find that chapter to reference it) but from what I recall, Amy didn't realise it until Taylor started getting intimate. So it wasn't as obvious as she's making out now.
143, from Taylor's perspective:
I moved toward her and sat on the bed next to her, then ran my fingers through her hair as I drew her into a kiss. This time there was no hesitation on my part. This time, I wanted this as much as she did, and for the same reasons. Our second kiss was wonderful and set off all the fireworks they were meant to set off. JoyDesireLove. She wrapped her arms around me and kissed more passionately.
RecognitionWorry. She broke the kiss. HorrorPain. "Oh god, Taylor, what have you done? DisgustGuilt.
That is the first physical contact they'd made. Sure, it took Amelia a few seconds to spot it (she was a little distracted), but she did spot it and reacted with horror, disgust and guilt. So, y'know. Close enough.
Secondly, Amy did it to Vicky in canon. This very thing. And desperation or not, she would have known that she would never have been able to enjoy it, if what you're saying is true. And in fact, in canon, when she followed Jack Slash's advice and followed her impulses, she did spend intimate time with Vicky, and she did enjoy herself.
The first part is true. The second part is your fanon. Amy *immediately* regretted something that she did in a moment of despair and weakness. And never once did anything to suggest they were physically intimate at any point.
In short, this is reading as a 'we can't have these two being happy by means of a simple consensual brain mod, so we're gonna just have to wait till the straight girl decides to go lesbian'.
Which is all well and good, and very romantic, for a given definition of romantic, but is not borne out by canon. In-story canon or out.
Actually, it's EXACTLY what fits with canon. Both my own and Wildbow's. You're thinking with the wrong part of your brain again.
In even shorter, you're cock-blocking them for drama. Fucking drama.
Two people sat down, talked about something one of them wanted to do, but the other had extremely good reasons for it not to be done, and the pair came to a mutual agreement based upon soul searching and respectful conversation where they both walked away from it happy and in good spirits.
... In what bass ackwards worldview is THAT drama?
For reasons entirely disassociated from wanting to see Taylor and Amelia get that hot action on, I don't like it. I won't stop reading, but I'm withholding my Like.
The only reasons are things you made up or remembered wrong. And the hot action. So. I'm going with you just being hung up on the hot action.
Ya know, i think Riley could pull it off. Super Subtle mods, i bet thats even what the camel fat was about, testing to see how good Amelia's bio sense really is so they can make adjustments to taylor without her noticing.
Yeah. You do realize that if it DOES happen naturally, Amelia's going to be suspicious. She WILL ask. And Taylor cannot lie to her (successfully, at least). So toss subtle mods out.
Unless Taylor doesn't know.
Clarice: I'm HALPING!
Amy/Taylor: We are extremely conflicted. On one hand- this is guilt free. On the other hand, it's a horrifying violation of trust.
On the third hand... now we mostly just feel really stupid for ever trusting Bonesaw with this level of access in the first place. Seriously, what the fuck's wrong with us?
It doesn't 100% jive with my memory of the scene, but it is close enough that I don't think it matters and makes perfect sense. Also, Taylor getting intimate is probably what flicks on the neon sign.
It being the things she did to Vicky is part of the hangup. It reminds her of her weakest moment. Also, I don't recall her getting intimate with Vicky at all in canon; Vicky immediately freaked out and wouldn't let her fix it. I guess it wouldn't be the first major bit of info I've forgotten from canon, though.
Edit:
Oh, and I think the unspoken motivation is "holy shit please don't do the same thing you did before which led you to kill yourself, even if it might go differently this time."
Nope. Just required physical contact. Or healing pod and Yggdrassil, I suppose. It's not something that could be seen through Taylia. The attraction, yes, certainly. But Amelia could easily sense if Taylor felt ill, too... she'd need contact to know what was causing the illness.
Also- yeah, the whole "your original killed herself and this is associated in my subconscious with that" may be a factor. Not NEARLY the factor that guilt-over-Vicky is.
Amelia needs to be constantly teasing Taylor with physical things
Sadly, Amelia's the more passive one in the relationship. It's a good idea, however.
Rapture would probably suggest it.
Okay, this is Worm as written by Wildbow. Would Amy have stopped short, if indulging herself fully would have given her more mental trauma, later? (Birdcage, people).
Also, and most notably - in all the time Amy had Vicky to herself, she never once removed the brain adjustment that made Vicky love her. If it was so distasteful, that's the first thing that she would have fixed.
I seriously doubt it, and so has everyone else who's commented on the issue. So you have your interpretation, we have ours.
And Amy HAD to leave that mod in. It was the only thing keeping her loving sister from murdering her in the most horrific way possible. Which would still be exponentially less horrible than what Vicky was living through.