Question on new thread called Back up your claims?

[Venumize]

Hey mods I had a question and wanted to ask in general if it was fine or not first before posting the thread. A brief explanation is needed I suppose.

I was told to take a discussion on what is or isn't canon to a discussion thread or in rants.

Having taken a quick look around I saw nothing like this exactly figured why not make my own? Nothing for this anime/manga and nothing about for what is or isn't canon. In short when an author or commenter says something is canon and you believe otherwise you would @ them in this new thread inside of rants asking for them to back up their claims to stay within the rules.

As Rule 1 is a bit more relaxed inside of rants it seems like this would be allowed in there, and being a bit more on the nose due to the annoyance of having to go elsewhere seems perfectly allowed.

The planned thread title is "What is or isn't canon - Back up your claims" or if that is still too much in rants then just the first part of that.

Thoughts?

 

[LurkingInTheDeceit]

The planned thread title is "What is or isn't canon - Back up your claims"

Click to shrink...

"Canon or Fanon?"

Thoughts?

Click to shrink...

Not a mod, but there's literally a thread in rants for insulting each other, so one for canon disputes should be fine.

 

[Venumize]

Not a mod, but there's literally a thread in rants for insulting each other, so one for canon disputes should be fine.

Click to shrink...

True, just wanted no BS with it and this seemed this best way since I never post in that section and don't have the long term feel of what is kosher and what isn't.

 

[Keldin]

Edit: Note to self: Check Timestamps next time.

 

[alethiophile]

Creating such a thread would be fine.