Simonbob
Really? You don't say.
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2014
- Messages
- 1,118
- Likes received
- 12,580
If you read any of the WOG that JKR wrote about how things worked, you soon find that she really doesn't care.From a pure story-telling perspective, and more specifically, from the perspective of someone taking up JKR's work, this is some of the best writing that's ever been done in
a fanfiction work. Not only does it offer clarity in terms of the way that magic might very well work, but it generates so very many possibilities. It's the kind of thing
that JKR should have seen as being possible in the world she initially built (but didn't) and it took you to come along and offer this commentary.
She said in an interview, there's whatever the plot needs in Harry Potter. She doesn't worry about the lack of it being in before, even if it should have been.
It's only us fans that try logic, and what things to be stable, within it's own world.