This story was inspired by GopherAtl's "The Adventures of Feels and Tourette" with a bit of...
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
User | Total |
---|---|
JMHthe3rd | 9 |
Well that was touching. Lotta people just want to hurt Emma, but believable redemption fics are way better, IMO.
Emma's still got a bit of that manipulative bitch in her, but I imagine she'd eventually open up to Taylor after they've really rebuilt things.
Well that was touching. Lotta people just want to hurt Emma, but believable redemption fics are way better, IMO. Emma's still got a bit of that manipulative bitch in her, but I imagine she'd eventually open up to Taylor after they've really rebuilt things.
Accepting some amount of punishment is an important part of any redemption plotline unless you want it to come off as them just getting away with their crimes with author support. Emma here seems like she realizes this but doesn't quite know how to go about it productively.in my opinion it should be a bit of both I think that Emma should pay but at the same time I think she should get redemption
... which is itself pretty believable, really.Accepting some amount of punishment is an important part of any redemption plotline unless you want it to come off as them just getting away with their crimes with author support. Emma here seems like she realizes this but doesn't quite know how to go about it productively.
Yup. I like redemption stories but doing them right requires the author to keep in mind exactly how horrible their crimes are and the character flaws that lead to them. A lot of stories just have them up and decide they are done being evil and suddenly they are redeemed. This one has done a great job so far.
That option is on the table, make no mistake about it, but it's a last resort kind of option, what with the high risk of horrible blowback and all.I have to admit, when I read "Sophia had to go." I thought for a moment that she had a more final solution in mind. (Not that I would object).
And after they discuss it a few more times, they will actually remember her saying it."I'm going into therapy, and I'm going to spend a long time making it up to Taylor." I paused and took a deep breath, blinking so fresh tears rolled down my cheeks. "But I'm afraid of what Sophia's going to do. Back there in the hall she . . . she said she was going to make Taylor pay."
I only had to wait a few moments.
"Yeah, I heard her say that," Madison said.
"She whispered it," said Julia, "but I heard it too."
"Me too."
"Yeah, fuck Sophia. I heard it too."
Charlotte rolled her eyes. "Sure, why not? Count me in."
Yup. I like redemption stories but doing them right requires the author to keep in mind exactly how horrible their crimes are and the character flaws that lead to them. A lot of stories just have them up and decide they are done being evil and suddenly they are redeemed. This one has done a great job so far.
The best way to get passed a lie detector is to think you're telling the truth.
: )
-
I have to say it feels a little too smooth though. I mean, I expected some of the girls to refuse to change their stance on Taylor. Suicide is a hot button for a lot of people, after all.
And after they discuss it a few more times, they will actually remember her saying it.
Such is mob psychology.
What, Amelia isn't a valid Emma-redeemed fic?This is really cool.
I figure this is my favorite take on Emma's character I've read, not that this is saying much. I suppose the second would be One More Trigger, which is decent, but butterflies so early that that Emma might as well be an OC compared to the one we see in canon. (The other closest thing I can think of to a fic that redeems Emma after canon start is Breaking of Shadow Stalker. Which should tell you how deep I'm reaching, that I bother to count that. <_<)
Haven't read either of the latter. Amelia...I had honestly forgotten Emma showed up in that. Which just goes to show how much other stuff was going on, I guess.
Atonement doesn't feature Emma for a bit, but she later grows into a bigger role, and redeems herself.
Intrepid starts with Emma wanting to redeem herself, she's one of the four leading characters there.
I can recommend both stories, they are excellent.
Both....I love it. I'm not sure if I'm supposed to say 'D'awwwwww' or 'Dear god that's fucked up' but I love it to bitsies!
Maybe some bathrooms were made at different times as the school changed so had different doors installed? It works as an explanation just fine.One comment though; the stall doors in the girls' bathroom open outward (it's how Emma was able to trap Taylor in the stall in canon). Just saying.