What If Warhammer 40k thread

[Nour uchiha]

A thread for any Warhammer 40k what if's you can think of, not for arguing who is right, or the morality of any faction, especially the Imperium & Chaos, nor to discuss who will win, nor how possible for what if to happen, but where it will go after it happened, if you don't like the what if, ignore it or suggest something else.


With that out of the way, i will start with two possibilities:


Isha is indeed the tree of life, and Guilliman & Mortarion fight distracted the trash bag( aka Nurgle)enough, that Leman was able to sneak with her, with Isha too weak to resist Leman.


The Horus Heresy & The Roboutian Heresy loyal and traitor Primarchs alongside their legions appear in the Imperium & the Warp, with their plants & everything else included.

 

[Blue burrowing critter]

The two lost Primarchs are infact just that, lost, as in they were never found in the first place.

I know this is basically stated to be untrue in canon, but it would honestly be more interesting then, they died lol, the possibility that there are two planets ruled by Primarchs out there would be much more interesting than whatever happened to them to get erased.

The Carcharadons, Space Sharks are not any one type of space Marines, but a mix of Raven Guard, Night Lord, World Eater and Death Guard all together.

I'm wonder if the Black Templars have ever lost an entire chapters worth of Space Marines in say a warp anomaly or something else were they were cut off for a long time and presumed lost by the rest of the chapter, and when they finally returned they had a different name for any number of reasons after what they went through and ruled with it? Would be awesome.

What if ever pre-Primarch Reunion Legion was their own legion entirely? Or the division between Terran born Space Marines and the various home world's is too great to overcome and the legions split in two entirely.