• The site has now migrated to Xenforo 2. If you see any issues with the forum operation, please post them in the feedback thread.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.
  • The rules regarding NSFW links have been updated. See here for details.

Wish upon the Stars (Original Superhero cultivation sci fi litrpg)

Reader mode
john764 said:
I am utterly offended at this supposed chicken and dumplings recipe you presented.
What you made was more akin to chicken soup with dumplings, not at all what it should be, in my opinion that is. The only saving grace is he didn't just take canned biscuits and throw them in there and made it himself.

Sidenote, it wouldn't be near as good when they ate it as it would have been the next day or the day after, that is a fact.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

I based it on my grandmothers recipe, though I was purposefully vague. Her chicken and dumplings was amazing, and was always better eaten immediately lol.
 
Malcolm Tent said:
I based it on my grandmothers recipe, though I was purposefully vague. Her chicken and dumplings was amazing, and was always better eaten immediately lol.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

Understandable.
I just personally like chicken dumplings to be exactly that without a bunch of other additions since that's the way my family did it when I was growing up.

Now, on letting it set in the fridge a day or two after cooking it, I can guarantee you you're missing out on that my friend. By letting it sit overnight, or even a full day, you let the flavors all marry together to make it more than it was before.
 
I am in it for this worldbuilding, man. If the capital city also ready has a population of 100 mil, what's the total pop of the planet? Actually, what's the average pop of the plants under Unity's control, and how many planets does he control? The factions are interstellar, but are they intergalactic?
 
insertname099 said:
I am in it for this worldbuilding, man. If the capital city also ready has a population of 100 mil, what's the total pop of the planet? Actually, what's the average pop of the plants under Unity's control, and how many planets does he control? The factions are interstellar, but are they intergalactic?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
I mean even without magic/high level cultivator bullshit adding to it beyond making terraforming presumably easier, if we go with the biggest organizations having like 10% of the galaxies planets each then they are looking at like 10ish billion planets each with what's looking like real high trillions/quadrillions maybe of people on average on them if the current planet is the equivalent of the boonies. So basically functionally infinite either way.
 
Hoh, that's not a decision to make lightly... 2 can keep a secret only if one is dead, and in this world of Cultivation and Magic, probably not even then. Even making contracts to protect himself wouldn't help against a psychic-type cultivator... looking forward to seeing how you handle this.
 
Malcolm Tent said:
I put ten of her points into Might and five into Vitality at her request.

Jessica Evans- H rank. Ability: Lesser Florokinesis- grow and control plants, as well as repairing damaged plants fibers.

Might-11
Impact-2
Fantasy-7
Vitality-25
Creation-8

Skills: Lesser Horticulture, Minor Herbalism, Minor Flower Arrangement, Minor First Aid

Jessie's Might had been six originally and her Vitality fifteen.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
One of these is the wrong way around. Probably the first one, considering the second matches the numbers listed.
 
Clever, we might be starting to see the inklings of a focus here... from the start, he's always preferred payments in memories/skills, that's how he got his current video game build in the first place. Collective generstional learning... go long enough and he could easily be an entire planet's peoples' knowledge in one person, heh
 
Honestly dude, i'm really loving this story! Having read all you stories on QQ now, watching how much you have grown as a writer is kinda amazing! Keep up the good work!
Malcolm Tent said:
Minor Inventing Mastery
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Also, I thought he got Lesser Inventing from Benny's memories?
 
WinterPhoenix said:
That was a very unexpected twist, which wasn't just shoehorned in to subvert expectations. That's heckin rare, great job.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Was it? I was kinda expecting it from the first moment I heard about missing kids. Like, ah so those kids that return are the sleepers.

Anyway I'm so glad I was able to stock up like 50 chapters, this is one of my favorite stories to binge.
 
I doubt he's made enough waves for other candidates to know about him from his own actions, or from general searching. If it is another candidate, they are somehow getting leaked info from within WCP. I think the theory that it's connected to his parent(s) is more likely.
 
Goddamn nearly a 6.5x multiplier, that's pretty insane. So I've been wondering this, is his doom sovereign character linked to the DS mastery skill? Can he use skills that don't belong to any of the classes his DS character has? Maybe it would be beneficial to learn stuff like healing just in case one of his team gets injured and they don't have time. Basically my question is, can he learn all the skills from doom sovereign classes? It kinda seems like he should be able to cause it's doom sovereign mastery, not whatever his class is called mastery.
 
Enjoying the story a lot so far, nowhere near caught up yet, only on Chapter 55. There's just one thing that makes me really cringe, and it's how hard the protagonist simps and makes excuses for Shadowthorn. Not unrealistic, it's hardly rare for guys to treat hot sad girls with undeserved kid gloves, but christ it's rough to read stuff like this:
Malcolm Tent said:
Shadowthorn was the first one on the shuttle, not taking much time to look at us. I could tell she wanted to avoid Callie as much as possible, and it sent another pang of sadness through me when I saw her sitting alone. I wished I had some way to talk to Callie about trying to make amends with Shadowthorn, for her own sake as much as the older woman's. It seemed like most of the fault there was with Midknight,
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Like sure, maybe this would be true if Shadowthorn was a total stranger, or if Midknight straight-up raped her, but no. She chose to whore it up with a married guy, and chose to play best friend to the girl whose life she was knowingly choosing to help tear apart. If she'd played the distant mentor role it'd be one thing, you could argue she owes nothing to a stranger and never pretended at being anything more. But pulling what she did puts her at least within shouting distance of Midknight (from the information presented as of 55) as far as responsibility and shittiness is concerned. Sure she "feels bad about it", but who gives a shit? She's still with the guy, and her attempts at friendliness come off as a self-indulgent attempt to have her cake and eat it too.

The last part makes her more distasteful to me, not less. Say someone abuses you, sends you into the hospital in agony, and you never really fully recover from some of the injuries. Then they periodically show up acting all apologetic and wanting to be best friends again, while still occasionally beating you (but they act super sad about it!) Fucking gross behavior, almost worse than someone who just says "Yeah I hate you and want to hurt you whenever possible lol".

Sure, she shouldn't be harmed or anything, but being sad and guilty and losing some friendships forever (and perhaps the relationship turning out less fulfilling than she'd like) in an otherwise pretty good life is better than what she deserves. It'd be one thing if this was "yeah she's trash and Midknight is even bigger scum" but treating her like some poor little woobie based on what he knows feels grotesque.

Edit: Forgot to mention the other obvious factor: That her sticking with him as he pulls his manipulative shit (and taking part in it) makes her complicit in it. Literally the only thing which could turn my view of this character around is if it comes out that he's flat-out threatening her into compliance.
 
Last edited:
Blundo said:
Enjoying the story a lot so far, nowhere near caught up yet, only on Chapter 55. There's just one thing that makes me really cringe, and it's how hard the protagonist simps and makes excuses for Shadowthorn. Not unrealistic, it's hardly rare for guys to treat hot sad girls with undeserved kid gloves, but christ it's rough to read stuff like this:

Like sure, maybe this would be true if Shadowthorn was a total stranger, or if Midknight straight-up raped her, but no. She chose to whore it up with a married guy, and chose to play best friend to the girl whose life she was knowingly choosing to help tear apart. If she'd played the distant mentor role it'd be one thing, you could argue she owes nothing to a stranger and never pretended at being anything more. But pulling what she did puts her at least within shouting distance of Midknight (from the information presented as of 55) as far as responsibility and shittiness is concerned. Sure she "feels bad about it", but who gives a shit? She's still with the guy, and her attempts at friendliness come off as a self-indulgent attempt to have her cake and eat it too.

The last part makes her more distasteful to me, not less. Say someone abuses you, sends you into the hospital in agony, and you never really fully recover from some of the injuries. Then they periodically show up acting all apologetic and wanting to be best friends again, while still occasionally beating you (but they act super sad about it!) Fucking gross behavior, almost worse than someone who just says "Yeah I hate you and want to hurt you whenever possible lol".

Sure, she shouldn't be harmed or anything, but being sad and guilty and losing some friendships forever (and perhaps the relationship turning out less fulfilling than she'd like) in an otherwise pretty good life is better than what she deserves. It'd be one thing if this was "yeah she's trash and Midknight is even bigger scum" but treating her like some poor little woobie based on what he knows feels grotesque.

Edit: Forgot to mention the other obvious factor: That her sticking with him as he pulls his manipulative shit (and taking part in it) makes her complicit in it. Literally the only thing which could turn my view of this character around is if it comes out that he's flat-out threatening her into compliance.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

She was a teenager who got manipulated by someone much more powerful than she was. The difference in Focus and Perception alone make the entire thing pretty shady on his part. I personally sympathize with her, but enough people disliked it that I scrapped the redemption arc. As far as I'm concerned he was the one who broke his vows, all she did was have sex with a guy she liked. Sure he was married, but that's his business not hers.

I've been cheated on before, and I didn't have any particular animosity toward the guy who did it. He didn't know me or have a reason to give a shit. I know that's not the average view on things, but I only really think people are responsible for themselves. The person in the wrong is the person who agreed to stay faithful and didn't. If my partner doesn't respect our relationship why would I expect a stranger to do it?

Regardless like I said people weren't fans so I scrapped the arc. She's mostly kind of faded into the background in the recent chapters.
 
Malcolm Tent said:
She was a teenager who got manipulated by someone much more powerful than she was. The difference in Focus and Perception alone make the entire thing pretty shady on his part. I personally sympathize with her, but enough people disliked it that I scrapped the redemption arc. As far as I'm concerned he was the one who broke his vows, all she did was have sex with a guy she liked. Sure he was married, but that's his business not hers.

I've been cheated on before, and I didn't have any particular animosity toward the guy who did it. He didn't know me or have a reason to give a shit. I know that's not the average view on things, but I only really think people are responsible for themselves. The person in the wrong is the person who agreed to stay faithful and didn't. If my partner doesn't respect our relationship why would I expect a stranger to do it?

Regardless like I said people weren't fans so I scrapped the arc. She's mostly kind of faded into the background in the recent chapters.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
I wasn't aware there had been discussion of it. I was just reading the story and had a strong enough reaction to it that I decided to make a post. Sorry if this has just been retreading old ground.

Honestly I think the "she wasn't the married one" reasoning falls extremely flat when she chooses to become a friend to the daughter then continues the affair. At that point she is knowingly causing harm to somebody she does profess to give a shit about. It's no longer some stranger. That's before one even questions the fundamental premise that you don't owe a stranger a basic level of decency. Consider the following scenario: You are walking down the street, and two strangers are coming the other way. They pause, and one of them says "Hey, I'll hold onto my friend here while you punch him in the face, then we can split what's in his wallet." You don't know the guy, you don't have a reason to give a shit about him, and the friend's betrayal is absolutely worse. If their friend doesn't respect them, why should a stranger? And yet I think most people would agree that you'd need to be a total piece of shit to go along with the plan. Nearly everyone I know would much rather get punched in the face and lose a wallet than get cucked by their spouse or discover their dad was having an affair with their best friend. Knowingly participating in an affair is being the person who agrees to that plan.

Unless the stats rise to the level of outright mind control (in which case like I said, flat-out rape), meaning she quite literally could not say no, she's garbage. Another person being an even bigger piece of shit doesn't change that any more than the existence of Ted Bundy excuses a lesser killer. And that's just the affair itself, not even the disgusting attempts to still be friends. That's a situation where anyone with even the scantest trace of decency would understand that they need to let the other person choose to rekindle things (and accept that they quite likely never will) rather than inflict their presence upon them. Plus the whole 'staying with the father and participating in his manipulation of his daughter' thing.

Still, if you've scrapped it I guess there's no point me going on about it. Good to know, I was worried that it might become a big part of where the fic was going based on the most recent chapters I read.
 
Blundo said:
I wasn't aware there had been discussion of it. I was just reading the story and had a strong enough reaction to it that I decided to make a post.

Honestly I think the "she wasn't the married one" reasoning falls extremely flat when she chooses to become a friend to the daughter then continues the affair. At that point she is knowingly causing harm to somebody she does profess to give a shit about. It's no longer some stranger. That's before one even questions the fundamental premise that you don't owe a stranger a basic level of decency. Consider the following scenario: You are walking down the street, and two strangers are coming the other way. They pause, and one of them days "Hey, I'll hold onto my friend here while you punch him in the face, then we can split what's in his wallet." You don't know the guy, you don't have a reason to give a shit about him, and the friend's betrayal is absolutely worse. If their friend doesn't respect them, why should a stranger? And yet I think most people would agree that you'd need to be a total piece of shit to go along with the plan. Nearly everyone I know would much rather get punched in the face and lose a wallet than get cucked by their spouse or discover their dad was having an affair with their best friend. Knowingly participating in an affair is being the person who agrees to that plan.

Unless the stats rise to the level of outright mind control (in which case like I said, flat-out rape), meaning she quite literally could not say no, she's garbage. Another person being an even bigger piece of shit doesn't change that any more than the existence of Ted Bundy excuses a lesser killer. And that's just the affair itself, not even the disgusting attempts to still be friends. That's a situation where anyone with even the scantest trace of decency would understand that they need to let the other person choose to rekindle things (and accept that they quite likely never will) rather than inflict their presence upon them. Plus the whole 'staying with the father and participating in his manipulation of his daughter' thing.

Still, if you've scrapped it I guess there's no point me going on about it. Good to know, I was worried that it might become a big part of where the fic was going based on the most recent chapters I read.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

Her relationship with Callie was more in the vein of a prospective step mother trying to become friends with her. She was a mentor and a friend and she protected her because Midknight is a controlling dick but she did genuinely teach Callie and help keep her safe. She became her friend under false pretenses, but she does actually care, she just didn't really have a way to get out of the situation she was in without hurting someone, and getting pregnant kind of made the call for her.

As for the stats...it's not exactly mind control, but the ability to detect even slight shifts in microexpressions and body language combined with the ability to process those changes with superhuman brainpower makes you an expert manipulator. It's like having constant access to a lie detector and a team of people to help you plot out how to use that information.

You also need to understand that Midknight pretty much by necessity heavily isolated Annie by singling her out. He deprived her of any sort of support system and burning that last bridge with Callie was basically severing her last connection. What real option did she have but to stay with him, especially given they have a kid together and he has the political and economic juice to take Eric if he feels like it.

specifically he singled her out because he wanted to have a kid with another Shadow attuned Ascendant with hopes of getting one with a stronger power. That was his main goal, and he went to quite a bit of trouble to manage it. Granted that hasn't come up in story, but that's why I blame Midknight, because while Annie was a stupid impulsive teenager who got manipulated, Midknight KNEW what he was doing, and he did it on purpose. Seriously, he is a HUGE asshole.
 
Wait, can't Wish be used to undo the brainwashing on Cark's sister? Also I am betting that the puppetmaster is one of the students
 
"His eyes burned with intensity" - isn't a viable phrase, "Eyes burned with intense ___ (insert emotion here)" is but "burned with intensity" doesn't work cause intense what? Intensity is an adjective it doesn't have a meaning on its own.
Additionally, even "burned with intense hate" is a meh phrase cause "eyes burned" already signifies how strong the hate in case of this example is so adding "intense" would be redundant, lots of writers do that, just pile on adjectives, sometimes less is more.

I am curious why no one ever shared memories or skills, just gave away, it's as good a payment as giving it up but more people would be willing to do it.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

  • Total: 3 (members: 1, guests: 2)
    Back
    Top