Nikas_Zekeval
Know what you're doing yet?
- Joined
- May 12, 2022
- Messages
- 143
- Likes received
- 2,351
I feel like the excuse against a lawsuit would be that they aren't denying her because she is a parahuman that didn't conform but because of x reason, which is something that happens in real life. Plus if the government can get away with violating outed parahumans' rights to privacy I can imagine the courts siding with the colleges if it comes down to it, especially considering the courts in Worm allowed the travesty that is the Canary trial to happen.
The problem is? If Earth Bet America is this much a dystopian hell hole where becoming a parahuman strips you of most human rights?
Then a major conceit of this story becomes impossible. Taylor would not be allowed to refuse power testing nor becoming an active Ward. After all fully documenting her powers is for her own good. As is branding her a Ward for all to see according to Gauss in the first interlude.
No, at a bare minimum the PRT has to at least pay lip service civil rights and privacy of parahumans, including and especially ones that are not affiliated with them and without criminal records.
So let's dial back the grimderp, okay?
It is mentioned that leaving the Wards/Protectorate is very difficult and carries various consequences, and while we don't really see an example of that in canon due to the only example of a Ward leaving I can think of being Lily that can be summed up due to the Protectorate/PRT's dirty laundry being aired at the time and Lily joining the Undersiders almost immediately after which probably stopped the organization from using their usual methods. So it can be reasonably inferred that the Protectorate does have methods to go around the Youth Guard regarding Wards who don't fully sign on once they turn eighteen.
Yeah, remember the multi-arc hell Browbeat went through to resign from the Brockton Bay Wards? No? Because it didn't happen. He left when his parents pulled him out. So it is possible, at wost like canceling a cable, streaming, or cell phone subscription. Maybe a bit of tedium, some sales rep trying to offer you a deal to change your mind, but ulimately if you want to go, they can't stop you.
In Lily's case, her being an oprhan meant the PRT managed to hold her guardianship, and didn't they fudge her birthdate in the name of 'security' to keep her a Ward past her 18th birthday? OTOH she had been part of the Wards for years at this point, she already drunk the Kool Aid, she just was tired of being yanked around to different departments because they didn't have to move parents with her as well, so she was easier to send.