Fixing the Atlas Arc
AndrewJTalon
Experienced.
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2015
- Messages
- 4,805
- Likes received
- 152,781
One of many issues with the Atlas Arc is that the politics are... Well, stupid. CRWBY were trying so hard to be "topical" that they failed to realize... It makes zero sense in-universe. It also doesn't help that CRWBY's understanding of real world politics is equivalent to the average Redditor's: Non-existent.
Atlas isolating itself and declaring a blockade... Was a stupid move. On every level. Unity is needed across the entire planet, especially with the CCTnet down, and Ironwood would know that. His belief in Atlas' superiority is immaterial, he would still want as many resources as possible and to work with his allies to figure out what Salem was up to.
And Jacques wants to end the blockade so he can make money... Makes him the bad guy? The world runs on Dust, him wanting to end this embargo is logical and the right thing to do. Yeah, he's a jerk and of course he wants more money-While providing a necessary resource to the entire planet. Why are you making the villain the guy in the right?
And Robyn Hill's little group steals supplies but we never see them actually distribute it to Mantle's citizens. They could have at least been seen fixing up a wall or two but no, because she's the underdog she's automatically the one in the right. Robin Hood stole from an illegitimate king to give to the poor he was exploiting, while still supporting the legitimate king to return and make things right: He wasn't Che Guavara. It betrays an overly simplistic and idiotic view of the world.
So, here's my suggestion for fixing the biggest issues with the Atlas Arc:
You know what the main issue for Atlas should be? Whether or not to take revenge on Menagerie for the actions of the White Fang. One faction in government wants to declare war on Menagerie and bomb the shit out of them, the other side wants to figure out what the hell happened. Ironwood and Hill can be on the side that is more moderate, Jacques and another military leader (Like Jinjur Hardy, the OC I made to be Ironwood's foil) can be on the Pro-War side.
Ironwood is opposed to declaring war on Menagerie when the world is already in chaos, he knows it won't help, and it will divert resources away from the Amity Project. Robyn Hill is against it because she's been looking over intelligence reports and it's clear that something bigger is going on. She and Ironwood can still be at odds because they're still political rivals, but they can work together on the important things, like the survival of life on Remnant.
On the other side, Jacques Schnee and Jinjur Hardy can be manipulated by Watts into wanting war. Jacques so he can make money off of it, and get more power, and Jinjur Hardy can get more power and become the defacto ruler of Atlas, and then Remnant through conquest.
This also means that Ruby has every incentive to tell Ironwood about Salem's immortality, and RWBYJNOR have an actual reason to be in Atlas aside from the Relic: They can provide testimony and evidence that Cinder is behind all of this, that Menagerie isn't backing the White Fang that has gone rogue (Blake also has a purpose here beyond yuribait) and that Salem is the real enemy.
Ironwood falling from grace due to Vytal and having to contend with Hardy as a rival, and make alliance with Robyn Hill's group, means you can have a rebellion against an authoritarian government (When Jacques or his candidate wins and Hardy gets in full power) without assassinating Ironwood's character or making anyone look stupid or evil. You can still have climatic final fights, with the added bonus that it actually MEANS SOMETHING and RWBYJNOR can win against some foes.
It's a very simple fix and all you had to do was not be stupid... But CRWBY couldn't even rise to the level of incompetent.
Atlas isolating itself and declaring a blockade... Was a stupid move. On every level. Unity is needed across the entire planet, especially with the CCTnet down, and Ironwood would know that. His belief in Atlas' superiority is immaterial, he would still want as many resources as possible and to work with his allies to figure out what Salem was up to.
And Jacques wants to end the blockade so he can make money... Makes him the bad guy? The world runs on Dust, him wanting to end this embargo is logical and the right thing to do. Yeah, he's a jerk and of course he wants more money-While providing a necessary resource to the entire planet. Why are you making the villain the guy in the right?
And Robyn Hill's little group steals supplies but we never see them actually distribute it to Mantle's citizens. They could have at least been seen fixing up a wall or two but no, because she's the underdog she's automatically the one in the right. Robin Hood stole from an illegitimate king to give to the poor he was exploiting, while still supporting the legitimate king to return and make things right: He wasn't Che Guavara. It betrays an overly simplistic and idiotic view of the world.
So, here's my suggestion for fixing the biggest issues with the Atlas Arc:
You know what the main issue for Atlas should be? Whether or not to take revenge on Menagerie for the actions of the White Fang. One faction in government wants to declare war on Menagerie and bomb the shit out of them, the other side wants to figure out what the hell happened. Ironwood and Hill can be on the side that is more moderate, Jacques and another military leader (Like Jinjur Hardy, the OC I made to be Ironwood's foil) can be on the Pro-War side.
Ironwood is opposed to declaring war on Menagerie when the world is already in chaos, he knows it won't help, and it will divert resources away from the Amity Project. Robyn Hill is against it because she's been looking over intelligence reports and it's clear that something bigger is going on. She and Ironwood can still be at odds because they're still political rivals, but they can work together on the important things, like the survival of life on Remnant.
On the other side, Jacques Schnee and Jinjur Hardy can be manipulated by Watts into wanting war. Jacques so he can make money off of it, and get more power, and Jinjur Hardy can get more power and become the defacto ruler of Atlas, and then Remnant through conquest.
This also means that Ruby has every incentive to tell Ironwood about Salem's immortality, and RWBYJNOR have an actual reason to be in Atlas aside from the Relic: They can provide testimony and evidence that Cinder is behind all of this, that Menagerie isn't backing the White Fang that has gone rogue (Blake also has a purpose here beyond yuribait) and that Salem is the real enemy.
Ironwood falling from grace due to Vytal and having to contend with Hardy as a rival, and make alliance with Robyn Hill's group, means you can have a rebellion against an authoritarian government (When Jacques or his candidate wins and Hardy gets in full power) without assassinating Ironwood's character or making anyone look stupid or evil. You can still have climatic final fights, with the added bonus that it actually MEANS SOMETHING and RWBYJNOR can win against some foes.
It's a very simple fix and all you had to do was not be stupid... But CRWBY couldn't even rise to the level of incompetent.