• An addendum to Rule 3 regarding fan-translated works of things such as Web Novels has been made. Please see here for details.
  • We've issued a clarification on our policy on AI-generated work.
  • Our mod selection process has completed. Please welcome our new moderators.
  • The regular administrative staff are taking a vacation, and in the meantime, Biigoh is taking over. See here for more information.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.
  • The rules regarding NSFW links have been updated. See here for details.

With This Ring (Young Justice SI) (Thread Fourteen)

HappyHappy (part 9) New
1st September 2013
08:36 GMT


"Okay? What kinda drugs?"

"Alchemical synthetic emotion inducers."

He hesitates for a moment while he tries to make sense of that. "Are they dangerous?"

"Ah… There's two parts to that answer. There's the question as to whether separating the natural association of emotion and stimuli is healthy for the individual or society, and then whether the particular means of delivering it is safe."

He gives me a small nod. "And the degree of risk. Alcohol isn't exactly safe, but we haven't tried to stop people drinking it."

"'We' as in Cadbury-?"

"No, the-." He recalls that we're here as owner and proxy, not as two superheroes. "Society. If we're only talking about something that's as dangerous as things people already use, that's not something to worry about."

"We've got at least thousands of years of data on what alcohol does to a person. This is new-. Or at least the mass production of it is new; there might be a group of alchemists out there somewhere who've been using it for a while. Initial observations are that it's chemically very harmful in one in fifty cases, but that's based on a sample size of fifty people. Dosing with the right emotion will overwhelm a person's judgement, and I know that because we had to fight an OMAC who could only feel anger."

He frowns in surprise. "Wait, anger? Why would someone make themselves angry? I though they'd be using… 'Joy', or something."

"Something else that's morally questionably about OMACs: the process appears to have some sort of emotional suppression aspect to it. Not totally surprising, given that they get memory wipes-."

"Yeah, I saw they were-. I just figured they acted like that because they didn't have memories so there wasn't much for them to feel things about."

"Me too, and the other OMACs evacuated him before I could ask him about it."

"We could..? Ask Bats..?"

"You could ask Bats."

"I'd feel better if you were there to hold my hand. Also, I can't fly in space."

"I can't ask Bats."

He looks mildly concerned. "How come?"

"I'm emotionally compromised."

"I didn't think you got emotionally compromised. I thought that was the whole… You, thing."

"I always know what I want. I have a problem when I have no idea how to get there. I-." I shake my head. "You remember -. I never liked Nabu-."

"Oh, everyone remembers what you did to Nabu."

"Right. Well. I respect Batman. I don't want to do that again, to be in that position again. I can't trust my practical judgements on this matter."

"You feel guilty."

"Of course I feel guilty!" Ah. "I mean, not about Nabu, as far as I'm concerned everything I did there was totally right-"

He raises his hands.

"-but Batman? And then there's the high likelihood that this is the best thing that could happen in utilitarian terms, and I…"

"So it's not so much that you're emotionally compromised as that you're practically compromised?"

"I-. Technically, but putting it that way sounds so inhuman."

"So… Okay, I'm not exactly happy about the way things are going either, but… You remember what you told me about us taking over the Earth by accident?"

"I rarely forget things."

He nods. "I thought it over afterwards, and… Yeah, I see what you mean, but there weren't any good options. It was time to take the Earth out of the oven, because it was done."

"No."

"What'd'you mean?"

"The current world order was done. It was on its way out after the sheeda-. You know the environmental thing, about how the Earth will be destroyed in thirty or forty years-"

He nods. "Yeah."

"-if we don't stop doing whatever. And it's nonsense. The Earth will still be here. Humans might be extinct, and we might have taken a lot of other species with us, but the Earth will be just fine. Humans don't need civilisation. We didn't start with it."

"So, what, just let ninety percent of people die?"

"It was an option. Doing what we're doing requires us to take over and expend our workforce. I guess we could have used genomorphs, or cloned Superman a few hundred times-."

"I don't think he'd go for that."

"Just giving people OMAC powers without mind wiping them creates the same risk that giving people access to Justice League resources without vetting them would. And you know that certain people in government would try exerting control over the situation. And them."

He nods. "Our options were to take over ourselves, or let-. Let most people die, so we could say we didn't. And so long as we give up power at the end, I think I can live with it."

"Nothing ever ends. It's unique in history, actually. If we get any more time travellers visiting, we should ask them about it."

"Human civilisation collapsing?"

"A group selected for altruism taking tyrannical power. Usually there's a lot of things dictators have to do to keep power that we're not doing. But-. Look, I'd love to discuss this-."

"The drugs, right."

"We don't know how dangerous they are, short, medium or long term. Doctor Mist is testing them now and that should tell us something, but given that the people selling them were using narcotic distribution techniques and responded violently to questioning, I'm assuming the worse while hoping for the best. If we can find out who's doing it and where, then we can check it's safe, and if it is? Maybe we can sort out a more legitimate distribution network for them. And a logistics train that doesn't involve hiding in my portal network. I'm peeved about that."

He raises his eyebrows. "'cause you're not getting cut in?"

"Because I want to make sure that I'm not making things worse by making it possible. But yes, if they're shipping things using my network then they can pay for it the same as everyone else, especially if it's for luxury items like narcotics."

Mr. Queen nods. "I'll get an internal investigation started."

"Thank you."

I go to stand, then pause, glancing at the screen.

I point to it with my right hand. "You want to do one of those? You've put more work into-."

"I'm-." He shakes his head. "I'm good, thanks."
 
Last edited:
He frowns in surprise. "Wait, anger? Why would someone make themselves angry? I though they'd be using… 'Joy', or something."

For some people LSD gives them nightmarish visions, but they still take it and it can have positive side-effects for them.

We could..? Ask Bats..?"

"You could ask Bats."

"I'd feel better if you were there to hold me hand

And get you out of there if things get messy.

"hold my hand"

people welling them were using narcotic distribution techniques and
"people selling"
Humans don't need civilisation
Strongly disagree.
 
He nods. "Our options were to take over ourselves, or let-. Let most people die, so we could say we didn't. And so long as we give up power at the end, I think I can live with it."
This is the sort of stuff I want to see Anarky's little cabal realize. Earth was in such a bad shape that if the Justice League didn't effectively take over, most of humanity would've died, or someone who would've taken advantage of the situation would've taken control. I kinda hope they'll have this realization after they do something they can't take back, forcing OL to take some extreme measures with them.
 
Last edited:
1st September 2013
08:36 GMT


"Okay? What kinda drugs?"

"Alchemical synthetic emotion inducers."
Makes them sound almost sensible when you put it like that, don't they? Like some kind of medication for emotional issues. Which is how some people are using them, but the problem is when they get carried away with themselves.

He hesitates for a moment while he tries to make sense of that. "Are they dangerous?"

"Ah… There's two parts to that answer. There's the question as to whether separating the natural association of emotion and stimuli is healthy for the individual or society, and then whether the particular means of delivering it is safe."
Too much of a good thing can be harmful, after all.

He gives me a small nod. "And the degree of risk. Alcohol isn't exactly safe, but we haven't tried to stop people drinking it."

"'We' as in Cadbury-?"

"No, the-." He recalls that we're here as owner and proxy, not as two superheroes. "Society. If we're only talking about something that's as dangerous as things people already use, that's not something to worry about."
And take the few cases of usage to dangerous excess as the price of making use of it? For instance, being so drunk you pass out, or drink driving.

"We've got at least thousands of years of data on what alcohol does to a person. This is new-. Or at least the mass production of it is new; there might be a group of alchemists out there somewhere who've been using it for a while. Initial observations are that it's chemically very harmful in one in fifty cases, but that's based on a sample size of fifty people. Dosing with the right emotion will overwhelm a person's judgement, and I know that because we had to fight an OMAC who could only feel anger."
Never mind the complications of decisions taken while in an altered state. A strong dose of Love might work like a date-rape drug, by making you inclined to do what the object of your affection (or obsession) asks you to.

He frowns in surprise. "Wait, anger? Why would someone make themselves angry? I though they'd be using… 'Joy', or something."

"Something else that's morally questionably about OMACs: the process appears to have some sort of emotional suppression aspect to it. Not totally surprising, given that they get memory wipes-."
A small amount of anger can act like a kick in the pants, get you moving in a depressive state or a dangerous situation. Too much... Well, ever hear of berserkers?

"Yeah, I saw they were-. I just figured they acted like that because they didn't have memories so there wasn't much for them to feel things about."

"Me too, and the other OMACs evacuated him before I could ask him about it."
Which is suspicious as hell. Why did they only show up when he was pacified? Why not when he went berserk?

"We could..? Ask Bats..?"

"You could ask Bats."
OL trying to stay hands-off with batman to avoid causing more trauma, eh?

"I'd feel better if you were there to hold my hand. Also, I can't fly in space."

"I can't ask Bats."
Skill issue, Ollie. Batman has powered armour, surely? How come you never made a power-suit? 😏 That could possibly lead to Green Arrow Beyond...

He looks mildly concerned. "How come?"

"I'm emotionally compromised."

"I didn't think you got emotionally compromised. I thought that was the whole… You, thing."
Eh, it's complicated. Just because he always knows what he wants... Doesn't mean he knows how to get it.

"I always know what I want. I have a problem when I have no idea how to get there. I-." I shake my head. "You remember -. I never liked Nabu-."

"Oh, everyone remembers what you did to Nabu."
Probably even new member who had no idea OL was capable of that.

"Right. Well. I respect Batman. I don't want to do that again, to be in that position again. I can't trust my practical judgements on this matter."

"You feel guilty."
Because he is guilty. He may have done it for the greater good of Earth, but he still gave Batman the tools he needed to become what he is now.

"Of course I feel guilty!" Ah. "I mean, not about Nabu, as far as I'm concerned everything I did there was totally right-"

He raises his hands.
Heh, Nabu was the villain there. Even if he might have eased off once he saw Giovanni was sticking with the deal... That's no excuse for what he did to the Zatara family.

"-but Batman? And then there's the high likelihood that this is the best thing that could happen in utilitarian terms, and I…"

"So it's not so much that you're emotionally compromised as that you're practically compromised?"
He knows the end state he wants: Earth fixed and Batman back to the way he was before OL messed with him. The problem is getting there, yes. Especially doing it without triggering another disaster.

"I-. Technically, but putting it that way sounds so inhuman."

"So… Okay, I'm not exactly happy about the way things are going either, but… You remember what you told me about us taking over the Earth by accident?"
Something like 'Better them, who won't abuse the power they have, than those who might or would'?

"I rarely forget things."

He nods. "I thought it over afterwards, and… Yeah, I see what you mean, but there weren't any good options. It was time to take the Earth out of the oven, because it was done."
A bit of hyperbole. Humanity might have survived it all, though pummelled back to primitive stages of development for a while.

"No."

"What'd'you mean?"

"The current world order was done. It was on its way out after the Sheeda-. You know the environmental thing, about how the Earth will be destroyed in thirty or forty years-"
And Power Rings can only do so much about that, especially with the causes still pumping out the damage.

He nods. "Yeah."

"-if we don't stop doing whatever. And it's nonsense. The Earth will still be here. Humans might be extinct, and we might have taken a lot of other species with us, but the Earth will be just fine. Humans don't need civilisation. We didn't start with it."
Wouldn't be the first time the slate got wiped clean. There's been more than a few mass extinctions already.

"So, what, just let ninety percent of people die?"

"It was an option. Doing what we're doing requires us to take over and expend our workforce. I guess we could have used genomorphs, or cloned Superman a few hundred times-."
Ironically what the Renegade is kind-of doing with his Kryptonian restoration project...

"I don't think he'd go for that."

"Just giving people OMAC powers without mind wiping them creates the same risk that giving people access to Justice League resources without vetting them would. And you know that certain people in government would try exerting control over the situation. And them."
Human instinct, really. Seeking the best angle for you and yours over everyone else. Even if that's bad in the long-term...

He nods. "Our options were to take over ourselves, or let-. Let most people die, so we could say we didn't. And so long as we give up power at the end, I think I can live with it."

"Nothing ever ends. It's unique in history, actually. If we get any more time travellers visiting, we should ask them about it."
Though I expect the league do want to get things working in something resembling the old system sooner rather than later, before people get to used to them being in charge...

"Human civilisation collapsing?"

"A group selected for altruism taking tyrannical power. Usually there's a lot of things dictators have to do to keep power that we're not doing. But-. Look, I'd love to discuss this-."

"The drugs, right."
You can talk about that philosophical stuff later. Right now, business.

"We don't know how dangerous they are, short, medium or long term. Doctor Mist is testing them now and that should tell us something, but given that the people welling them were using narcotic distribution techniques and responded violently to questioning, I'm assuming the worse while hoping for the best. If we can find out who's doing it and where, then we can check it's safe, and if it is? Maybe we can sort out a more legitimate distribution network for them. And a logistics train that doesn't involve hiding in my portal network. I'm peeved about that."
The source of them could legitimately have been altruistic. But one nasty link in the chain and suddenly you have cartels trying to profit from it.

He raises his eyebrows. "'cause you're not getting cut in?"

"Because I want to make sure that I'm not making things worse by making it possible. But yes, if they're shipping things using my network then they can pay for it the same as everyone else, especially if it's for luxury items like narcotics."
Or Medications, depending on how it pans out. After all, there's a fine line between the two states. ADHD medication is technically micro-doses of amphetamines, for instance.

Mr. Queen nods. "I'll get an internal investigation started."

"Thank you."
While OL has his own investigation going. Ideally they'll coordinate to avoid working at cross-purposes.

I go to stand, then pause, glancing at the screen.

I point to it with my right hand. "You want to do one of those? You've put more work into-."

"I'm-." He shakes his head. "I'm good, thanks."
For one thing, the more well-known his face is, the less anonymity he'll have in costume.

A lot of salient points covered there. Not just with the current case, but with the moral and ethical quandaries of the League's reluctant benevolent tyranny. None of them are politically trained or even so inclined. They never wanted to be ruling the world, but there was no-one else able to at that moment. The peril will be if a legitimate government comes forward for them to surrender authority to... 🤔 Can they trust them with that authority?
 
"Just giving people OMAC powers without mind wiping them creates the same risk that giving people access to Justice League resources without vetting them would. And you know that certain people in government would try exerting control over the situation. And them."

This is true, but at the same time the Justice League could have said "well that's going to happen and we'll just have to deal with it on a case by case basis as it does". There's also the "pinning everything on one failure point" with Brother Eye. There's certainly different decisions Batman could have made with different sets of downsides.

Though one part of this is, we haven't really seen the OMACs do that much. When they appear in story they're sort of generically standing around, helping clean up rubble. When we see them use their powers, it's usually because they've gone rogue and are fighting the SI.

It would be nice from a narrative perspective to see the OMACs actually deploying their incredible level of power and numbers to do something useful. Bringing down a heavy hitter, subduing a national military all on their own, completely dismantling a huge evil organization... something. I notice that neither the SI nor another of the people he's discussed this with, be they Wally or Artemis or Oliver here have suggested, "The OMACs will probably investigate this and take care of it." Even though an OMAC was affected by it.
 
This is true, but at the same time the Justice League could have said "well that's going to happen and we'll just have to deal with it on a case by case basis as it does". There's also the "pinning everything on one failure point" with Brother Eye. There's certainly different decisions Batman could have made with different sets of downsides.

Though one part of this is, we haven't really seen the OMACs do that much. When they appear in story they're sort of generically standing around, helping clean up rubble. When we see them use their powers, it's usually because they've gone rogue and are fighting the SI.

It would be nice from a narrative perspective to see the OMACs actually deploying their incredible level of power and numbers to do something useful. Bringing down a heavy hitter, subduing a national military all on their own, completely dismantling a huge evil organization... something. I notice that neither the SI nor another of the people he's discussed this with, be they Wally or Artemis or Oliver here have suggested, "The OMACs will probably investigate this and take care of it." Even though an OMAC was affected by it.
You've got a point and I'll try to do something about it, but the SI wouldn't go to a situation OMACs were handling because it would be redundant, and he isn't inclined to share information with them directly or ask for their help because he's disturbed by the program.
 
How many people are in the room? Was it a full board meeting with maybe 15 people, and how many know everything GA/OL know?
 
How many people are in the room? Was it a full board meeting with maybe 15 people, and how many know everything GA/OL know?

Considering OL was asking seemingly random CEO Oliver Queen to talk to Batman about something I'm guessing they were alone
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top