Not when you take into account that said new Confidant would need time and AP spent on her just to handle the inevitable complications.Yes, but also the same is true of a Confidant
So Celestia knew that Twilight would not listen to her on this, so she did not tell her. Velvet knows that Twilight would not listen to her...
I already have the Risen and did not need to further ruin any lives to get it. It also doesn't need lessons in how to get used to its body, has no people that personally know it leading to pesky questions about changes in behavior, and even disposes of itself when its time is up. A strictly superior bot for the AP grind.Yes, but also the same is true of a Confidant
We can even bring it to All In for that sweet marginal Lore bonus grind and not shed any tears if it dies, lmao
Mirror Twilight isn't the Element of Magic though. The Element of Magic is the Twilight that would be getting banished. It's her title and everything. Mirror Twilight is just a student of Canterlot High.
EDIT: And the way the "unreliable narrator" might come in is that the good may be less than promised, while the bad may be glossed over. But that kind of analysis is… hard to do with certainty. (That's the idea with unreliable narration.
Human Twilight becomes Earth element of magic further down the line in canon. My guess is Harmony will want to have its laser assembled and will ensure that Human Twilight becomes Element in short order. In fact we don't even know how and why Human Twilight came into being. She could have been generated from ether along with the others as backups copies. Velvet also does not act very rational right now. And we don't know how much control Harmony have over its bearers when it is fully charged, so it is better to be ready for sudden but inevitable betrayal if its has its own designs on the Glory. So it again came to how much we are willing to trust it.
This is why Harmony needs replacement Twilight. She is Isekay protagonist. Or have potential to be one. All you described are just bosses and mini-bosses to slay. Just don't forget to mention to Twilight that combination attacks are thing in the setting and she needs to rise relationship gauge with specific characters to unlock them.
Something that's been overlooked so far:
Velvet that suffers from her own decisions, from being unable to help due to her own moral restraints
Is God Evil because he allows Evil to happen?
I somewhat regret it even though a Harmony clue appeared. Now I'm wondering if we could tell human Twilight about Harmony and how her world is bathed in magic light so she can keep herself busy with that.
Yeah I think we should have left as soon as we got the Frangiclave. Which, well, I already was of that opinion before the last vote, but the results mostly just confirmed for me that yes, we should have been better off using that AP for something else in the real world rather than puttering around here longer.
Jade's already on it this turn, remember?
And there is also the chance of Step 2 needing the Step 1 ritual to actually be cast instead of just finished, if the knowledge to advance the ritual comes from the ritual. Or maybe Jade needs to study Selene again or another Alicorn.
It would have been if we had checked the internet, but nooooo...
That is once again making the same mistake the voting has always made with Twilight. In being to gentle, every single time the thread voted to be gentle and got worse off with Twilight.
Inconsequential.
It's not so much this is being ignored. It is the bedrock of discussion, just not really put to words. If the rolls succeed, and Velvet passes through the gate... Who is it that reached Glory?
My fear is that she will become an obstacle or try to do something with Silky or just GRAILBOMB Canterlot into opposing us, if she realizes the likely lethal things(that many posters want) that we will do to her if we have the chance, the desperation or indignation of a noblemare directed at Velvet is not something i want to read.
Not really, i'm sure she will have plenty of time in the future to oppose Velvet when she recovers her horn, and thus some capability and motivation, just like Sci-Twi when she meets with Sunset.
You know, I find it interesting that you seem to consider Sunset enough of a threat that you're insisting that she'll totally corrupt Mirror Twilight and have her cause issues for us in a meaningful time frame, and yet at the same time not enough of a threat to the point where you just ignore the possibility that she would do that same to a much more vulnerable real Twilight, who has many more reasons to actually be angry at us and hold a grudge against others in Equestria in general.
That would require Velvet to take any action with Twilight which GM confirmed will not happen under any circumstance. Velvet will not heal her Horn or send anybody do it themslevesl either, and nobody else will. Twilight only path left if we don't do the swap the Wolf's jaws.
Twilight only told us to never speak to her
On the one hand I want more Soft and pony Twilight interaction. On the other hand I don't like Velvet morals standing in the way of her helping others, be it pony Twilight or Human one. And being selfish to a degree is not a crime.
Twilight being threat to us while not being Wolfed is still improvement over her current situation.
If getting Mirror Twilight wasn't in the picture, then we wouldn't be having this vote at all.
I mean for players, not for Velvet. if we speak strictly about Velvet it shoud be obvious that she is not doing it to get free labor from Human Twilight.
She would likely be to depressed in the Asylum, because nothing good can happen to her if the swap happens i guess.
I did say that i was jumping to the worst case scenario didn't i?
The swap is better than the WOLF.
now would be a good time to make an account and join in on the 
.