• The site has now migrated to Xenforo 2. If you see any issues with the forum operation, please post them in the feedback thread.
  • An addendum to Rule 3 regarding fan-translated works of things such as Web Novels has been made. Please see here for details.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.
  • The rules regarding NSFW links have been updated. See here for details.

Esquestria: The House of the Sun - A pony cultist experience

We can do both of them, and I seriously doubt that Baldomare would suffer the embarassment of a failed Sacrament.

Actually, we already saw Axe perform a Sacrament, there were no rolls involved at all. The benefits of being a Name, hmm?
I think that is because the Names are giving something that is mechanically the same as a lesson or Influence coming from them: Guaranteed to succeed.

Even the things Velvet needs to do to get their Sacraments are either formalities or favors, they are literally exchanging the thing for other things while still having the thing.

Mastery is a hell of a benefit.
 
it's not. it's really a better idea than aiming for Moth 6, all things considered.

Then again... scrying for the strongest MOTH artifact.

It's likely to have a really high DC.
We can get up to a +93 Lantern bonus w/ a Lantern 4 reagent, so we'd have a decent chance and I think it'd be worth it. Even if the Moldywarp Stone was the only Moth 7 artifact in existence, scrying for the highest level available Moth artifact would still point us to a Level 6 artifact.

I'd prefer Baldomare to scry it, but she's going to be busy fir at least next turn at the minimum, and this is something we'd want to scry sooner rather than later.
 
We can get up to a +93 Lantern bonus w/ a Lantern 4 reagent, so we'd have a decent chance and I think it'd be worth it. Even if the Moldywarp Stone was the only Moth 7 artifact in existence, scrying for the highest level available Moth artifact would still point us to a Level 6 artifact.

I'd prefer Baldomare to scry it, but she's going to be busy fir at least next turn at the minimum, and this is something we'd want to scry sooner rather than later.
we're actually in not THAT much of a rush, as we're on track to get Moth 5 on turn 23 anyway, so we COULD wait for Baldomare to be free. We'll see.

Should we scry for OTHER lvl 6 sacraments too, I wonder? Forge 6 artifact might even be somewhat more useful, as it could raise our Forge roll for Forge Sacrament and give us 2 scraps when studied, making it far more likely we'll make it in time to Forge Sacrament... Same for Winter 6.

...at least scrying ritual is relatively cheap. But really, We should work on the expeditions we have first.


Current bits (money): 451

This turn's available bits: 516 (196 from previous turn, 160 from monthly salary, 53 from Rarity, 107 from this turn's Rarity's commission)

We have 451 bits right now. next turn we should add 160 from salary, and probably another 50 or so from Rarity's work, so actually around 661 next turn.


TURN 22: 661 bits.

what are we going to spend them on in the near future?

Let me look at the expeditions, I want to estimate how much they're likely to cost us.


Location: Within the depths of Mount Canterlot, there is a warded door. Rank with the authority of a solemn threshold. It would be foolish to open it before being prepared, and there is only one way to find out what lies behind it.

Expected duration: LONG

Base cost: 8 bits (you must have at least 120 bits per creature sent)

Expected dangers: UNKNOWN (expedition not scouted)

Realistically I'll think we're basically sending Biedde and Axe. MAYBE we'll add a third one (Mareinette? Selene? Probably not Selene, it would consume two actions from her... though we COULD afford it), so that's 240 (or 360) bits in reserve, though from past expeditions I expect us to actually spend only 40% (I'll round it up to 50%) of it, so actually only 120 or 180 bits, with the rest refunded the following turn.

Location: Tall Tale is a growing city, surrounded on one side by a quickly-disappearing forest, and by tall mountains on the other. Those mountains, according to your agents, are currently infested by changelings. You could sneak in there, to either strike at the changelings yourself, steal from them, or maybe even PLANT something you would like your constables to find later. But unfortunately, this endeavor will not be without dangers.

(NOTE: This expedition will DISAPPEAR if the Lunar Bureau raids it before you do. But an expedition sent here will arrive before the Bureau raids it, if both actions are taken on the same turn.)

Expected duration: MEDIUM

Base cost: 7 bits (you must have at least 70 bits per creature sent)

Expected dangers: Sneaking past your own agents shouldn't be hard, since you know their every move. And there are changelings in the mountains themselves. Other than that, anything else is UNKNOWN (expedition not scouted)
Again, probably only 2 people sent. I imagine Mareinette + either Selene (1 action cost out of 3) or Biedde. that 140 bits reserved, and again I expect us to ACTUALLY spend only half of them.


Location: According to Baldomare, you won't be able to find it on any map. "By its very definition", is how she said it. Still, she mentioned the two of you will be heading east. (You may only go to this expedition if you take Baldomare with you. And as a rule, you two must go alone. This will grant you Baldomare's Sacrament for the Lore of Secret Histories.)

Expected duration Action cost: 1 Baldomare action, 1 Velvet Covers action.

Base cost: The whole round trip, and the list of equipment she told you to buy for both of you (but mostly for you), costs a grand total of 40 bits.

Expected dangers: "Of course there will be dangers. Living is dangerous! And you are not telling me that you have been walking around the Mansus every now and then but that you're scared of a little hike, are you?"
the SH Sacrament expedition. ONLY 40 bits, nearly negligible really.



mh... could we manage to do them ALL next turn?

EXPEDITION 1: SH SACRAMENT. 40 bits, 1 velvet action, 1 Baldomare action

EXPEDITION 2: Changeling Hive (because I'd rather do it before the bureau goes there): Mareinette + Selene (Biedde is busy giving us Edge Influence for Sacrament.

EXPEDITION 3: ...we can't manage to do it in the same turn, so delayed for turn 23 I imagine.

FOLLOWERS ACTIONS:

Rarity: 1
Jade Whistle: 1
Fluttershy: 1
Filthy Rich: 1 (UNCERTAIN)
Baldomare: 1
Mareinette: 1

Velvet Axe: 1
Biedde: 1
Selene: 3 2 1
Household servants: 1

Axe might be two actions if we're lucky.

Jade: Likely more Memory of Light research
Baldomare: SH Sacrament expedition
Mareinette and Selene: changeling expedition
Biedde: Edge Influence
Rarity, Fluttershy, FIlthy Rich, Servants, 1 Selene: 2 cover your bases instances, +2 velvet actions.

Leftover: 1 (or maybe 2) Axe actions, 1 Selene action (probably soothing dreams? search for a ritual site? dream spying?).

We could send Axe instead of Selene on the expedition if we wanted to.

VELVET ACTIONS.

4+2 (cover your bases) + 1 free social.

Social: Probably Filthy + Spoiled Rich.
1) Baldomare SH expedition
2) Biedde Edge fight
3) Study artifacts/books
4) At least one FO, let's be real. possibly more.
5) ?
6) ?
 
Thinking about a Cadance!Quest negaverse where the paranoid section of the playerbase finally got a vote off the ground to spend AP on a turn long +40 "The Nature Of Loyalty" boost and check over Velvet Covers despite AP hell.

Oooh, I would love to see that too! Now that I got reminded of Cadance!Quest's existence, I would like to see what is happening from her perspective more.
 
Axe might be two actions if we're lucky.

Jade: Likely more Memory of Light research
Baldomare: SH Sacrament expedition
Mareinette and Selene: changeling expedition
Biedde: Edge Influence
Rarity, Fluttershy, FIlthy Rich, Servants, 1 Selene: 2 cover your bases instances, +2 velvet actions.

Leftover: 1 (or maybe 2) Axe actions, 1 Selene action (probably soothing dreams? search for a ritual site? dream spying?).

We could send Axe instead of Selene on the expedition if we wanted to.

VELVET ACTIONS.

4+2 (cover your bases) + 1 free social.

Social: Probably Filthy + Spoiled Rich.
1) Baldomare SH expedition
2) Biedde Edge fight
3) Study artifacts/books
4) At least one FO, let's be real. possibly more.
5) ?
6) ?

We need an AotL or two don't we for the Edge fight? How would we go about getting that? Also what do we need to raid the Hive for before the our goons do? There's no evidence that we need to get rid of or important loot we want to snatch from our own underlings. The Canterlot one promises a lot of good loot and profit, not sure what the Hive promises.

I know we probably want to keep a level 5 book in reserve for Baldomare emergency but we can read three books with a study action and I really want to read that book of Manehattan expeditions: it really looks like those manehattan expeditions will be profit central. and that leaves us with two reading slots for those level 5 books. Unless we can double up decipering the moth one?

Oooh, I would love to see that too! Now that I got reminded of Cadance!Quest's existence, I would like to see what is happening from her perspective more.

Yeah imagine it right after they discovered that Comet Feet existed and was by Velvet's bed but before the Luna reveal.
 
Last edited:
We need an AotL or two don't we for the Edge fight? How would we go about getting that? Also what do we need to raid the Hive for before the our goons do? There's no evidence that we need to get rid of or important loot we want to snatch from our own underlings. The Canterlot one promises a lot of good loot and profit, not sure what the Hive promises.

I know we probably want to keep a level 5 book in reserve for Baldomare emergency but we can read three books with a study action and I really want to read that book of Manehattan expeditions: it really looks like those manehattan expeditions will be profit central. and that leaves us with two reading slots for those level 5 books. Unless we can double up decipering the moth one?

I think we were told we can have any follower use an action to prepare an AotL circle, like the cult basically did for us before. So, 1 AotL per follower action we're willing to give, and I think it works for 2 Edge rolls if I remember right.

Two AotL total should be enough. 3 if we want to be absolutely sure, I suppose.


As for the changeling expedition, I'm assuming they have some valuable loot, or what would be the point of it being an expedition at all? I suppose changeling prisoners would have inherent value as ritual sacrifices (but we don't have a prison), but I find it likely they have either a few artifacts, or stuff worth bits.

That said, if we really don't care for the changelinge expedition, maybe we could just skip to Canterlot Part 3.

As for books, keep in mind we might need multiple rolls for the same book, ESPECIALLY ones we need to decript. I think we estimated the Moth 5 book to take 3 rolls, for example. But yeah, we should read the Canterlot one.
 
We need an AotL or two don't we for the Edge fight? How would we go about getting that? Also what do we need to raid the Hive for before the our goons do? There's no evidence that we need to get rid of or important loot we want to snatch from our own underlings. The Canterlot one promises a lot of good loot and profit, not sure what the Hive promises.
Depending on how things pan out this turn we may want to plant more Lore knowledge (or the ritual circles), but otherwise yeah, I think we're better off leaving the proto-hive alone in favor of the more valuable expeditions.

As for books, keep in mind we might need multiple rolls for the same book, ESPECIALLY ones we need to decript. I think we estimated the Moth 5 book to take 3 rolls, for example. But yeah, we should read the Canterlot one.
Three attempts to reach ~90% success chance is with two Lantern AotLs; three attempts w/ no AotLs only gets us to 66.5%, which would probably be okay enough if it weren't for the doom clock ticking in the background being dependent on our Moth level. Without any AotLs, it'd be five attempts to reach a similar success margin (~92%).

Lantern Influence would help a lot, but alas! Baldomare will most likely be busy giving us our SH Sacrament and we're unlikely to have the AP available to be willing to squeeze a CoI in there (though not impossible, I suppose). Maybe if we delay the Edge Sacrament to T23.
 
Last edited:
Three attempts to reach ~90% success chance is with two Lantern AotLs; three attempts w/ no AotLs only gets us to 66.5%, which would probably be okay enough if it weren't for the doom clock ticking in the background being dependent on our Moth level. Without any AotLs, it'd be five attempts to reach a similar success margin (~92%).

As it's a single action and an Aotl only applies to a single action wouldn't a single lantern Aotl apply to all book reading rolls for that action.
 
As it's a single action and an Aotl only applies to a single action wouldn't a single lantern Aotl apply to all book reading rolls for that action.
nah, AotL is not to a single action, it's to a single ROLL.

unless it's Edge. in that case I think it's to a single ROUND of combat (so 2 rolls).
 
And if I understand right we currently have an unused Lantern AOTL sitting around? And that's why we want to consider using our action refund on book studying? Sorry please have patience I'm catching up to what the plans were
basically. though Personally I'd rather study artifacts. We have Lantern 4 (useful to allow Selene to scry with really good rolls by using Lantern 4 and SH 3 from Artifacts), Winter 4 (admittedly not essential to anything, though like Lantern 4 it brings us closer to the Lantern and Winter sacraments...)

AND

IF WE'RE LUCKY

we might be able to study and keep the Frangiclave. Which is likely a Knock 6 or even 7 artifact, AND definitely the most powerful artifact currently in our possession. And among other things Knock is used in ALL summoning rituals...

With Knock, Edge and Lantern artifacts we can basically have ANYONE summon Mares in the Light for us (Summoning requirements: LANTERN 80, KNOCK 60, EDGE 60.), even Rarity or Comet or Jade.

like, ignoring pre-existing lores of the follower, with those artifacts and assuming an average +10 from the base stat, they'd roll +50 lantern, +70 minimum Knock, and +40 Edge.

Comet would have a better roll for Edge (another +10). Jade would have the Lantern Reroll. Selene would have a Knock reroll AND higher edge (+10). Our Names basically do it with certainty thanks to high base bonus, but generally speaking they're better used on more valuable actions (influences, lessons, their special exclusive actions...)
 
@OurLadyOfWires I just wanna say that having spent the last week or two reading the entire story, then rereading it more slowly to digest better, and going over pages and pages of old discussion I wanna say it's really impressive how well you were able to write all those nexus points where the direction of the story changed massively and make it all tie together with major plotlines and entire story-defining facts coming from unpredictable sources.
 
In context from above, summon the hypothetical MiTL - only Lantern would be the dicy part here, but that goes for everyone not Baldomare iirc?
 
In context from above, summon the hypothetical MiTL - only Lantern would be the dicy part here, but that goes for everyone not Baldomare iirc?
No, Jade's just fine with the Lantern roll, the thing she'd have trouble with the the Knock DC which is why it'd be really nice to be able to keep Frangiclave. And studying the Lantern 4 artifact not only lets Selene act as a scryer, but opens up using Biedde, DoA, and Selene as reliable summoners of MitLs.

And, on a related note, studying the Winter 4 artifact opens up similar summoning options for Windigos, letting Biedde, DoA, and Comet have a decent-to-good chance at summoning.

Basically, studying higher level artifacts gives us more flexibility about who is casting what.
 
I just remembered we got a Moth 3 artifact from raiding Copper's Cult. While it's a bit too low level to hide our Lores, I wonder if we can (assuming it works the right way) loan it to Cadence so that we can teach her up to a Seeker level.
 
I just remembered we got a Moth 3 artifact from raiding Copper's Cult. While it's a bit too low level to hide our Lores, I wonder if we can (assuming it works the right way) loan it to Cadence so that we can teach her up to a Seeker level.
That... could work if it was a higher level Artifact but with Celestia at Lantern 1 it seems very unsafe to leave Cadance with such a weak way to hide her lores.
 
I just remembered we got a Moth 3 artifact from raiding Copper's Cult. While it's a bit too low level to hide our Lores, I wonder if we can (assuming it works the right way) loan it to Cadence so that we can teach her up to a Seeker level.
too little too late. Celestia is Lantern 1 now, might be Lantern 2 by the beginning of next turn, and worst case lvl 3 by the beginning of turn 23.

The Artifact would only protect Cadance for one, maybe two turns. Anything short of a lvl 5 moth artifact is not worth the risk of teaching her
 
too little too late. Celestia is Lantern 1 now, might be Lantern 2 by the beginning of next turn, and worst case lvl 3 by the beginning of turn 23.

The Artifact would only protect Cadance for one, maybe two turns. Anything short of a lvl 5 moth artifact is not worth the risk of teaching her
That's a fair point.
Speaking of, I really hope either the Memory of Light or Selene's Winter action give us a lead on how to get rid of Daybreaker. The worst case scenario for Celestia's Lantern growing once per turn makes me worried that we won't be ready for All In, and even the best case scenario of it growing only every two turns is still cutting it kind of close for me.
 
Eh, if Celestia Lanterns Cadance she will see a mere dabbler just getting her hoofs wet after she saw Celestia wade into the pool first, which isn't too much of a concern provided that whatever method is used to expose Cadance to this stuff cannot be traced back to Velvet, which I will admit would be tricky. But if we can do that she'd probably be fine.

The issue with Velvet is that Celestia at a high enough Lantern will suddenly realize that Covers has been Olympic High Diving into the spooky magics since before Celestia ever knew her, and has been misleading her this entire time.
 
I just remembered we got a Moth 3 artifact from raiding Copper's Cult. While it's a bit too low level to hide our Lores, I wonder if we can (assuming it works the right way) loan it to Cadence so that we can teach her up to a Seeker level.
Oh! Huh! Good idea! @OurLadyOfWires, any thoughts if this artefact would give Cadance a chance at learning the lores..?

(Maybe it's unwise anyways, since I imagine Celestia will be Lantern 3 soon enough)
 
In which obsession becomes a virtue New
[Y] Return home, with Diary, Frangiclave, and something else besides. Or rather, someone. (End the dream, bringing Twilight Sparkle with you, and redistribute your remaining action points.)

The Velvet estate is home to many rumors and gossips.

Granted, maids and servants are as prone to whispering secrets to each other as they are to attending their actual duties. And everypony knows that, as a rule, noble households are already a nexus of gossiping to begin with.

However, over the last few months, the Velvet estate of Ponyville has certainly become… something else.

Its corridors, or at least the mind of its servants, have been filled with more intrigue than the average noble household. And it certainly has seen way more activity than it should have, considering how far it is from Canterlot and how unremarkable its Lady had been for so many years.

But rumors, just like fire, neither care nor discriminate, and they will spread as long as there is adequate fuel for them. Regardless of the past or pedigree of those they envelop.

And the recent guests of the Velvet estate, as well as the scandalous actions of the Lady herself, have been more than enough to spark many a controversy.



"You know, I have been thinking about our summoner these last few days. And I couldn't help but see a few parallels between her and the adepts of our time."



One of those rumors is about nopony other than good Baldomare.

Now, this isn't exactly a rumor per se. It is not a scandal, or a gossip, or even a peek into her elusive and tightly guarded past. This particular tidbit of conversation, that floats here and there among the servants, isn't really something that is either gleefully shared or jealously kept secret by whoever hears it.

In fact, it is more of an opinion than a rumor.

And that opinion is…

… that good Baldomare is actually a very bad conversation partner.



"[SECRET HISTORIES]?"

"Why I'm saying this? Wait, you haven't heard? Or perhaps it hasn't happened yet? What day is it… ah, but of course. Yes, yes, my apologies. I just happened to look ahead a little bit. You see, our summoner is coming back tonight, finally, and she will bring somepony back with her. A new guest, I suppose, to fill this house with."



Of course, good Baldomare is not without her fair share of fans and admirers. And those ponies will quickly jump to deny such slanderous claims.

However, the fact remains that, well, everypony agrees Baldomare knows everything.

And that makes her a great storyteller, for sure. A great storyteller, a wonderful advisor, and a very mischievous fortune teller for those who dare ask.

Still, wouldn't that make her a terrible conversation partner? After all, how can you have a proper conversation with somepony who already knows everything? Wouldn't that make it a lecture? A monologue? Or perhaps an exercise in futility?



"[FORGE]?"

"No, no, not that kind of guest. But you are right, in a sense. Or maybe you are coming from the right place? Well, it doesn't matter. Although I agree with you. Because maybe I shouldn't call that newcomer a guest…?"



Whatever the truth may be, the fact remains there are still ponies who are willing to engage good Baldomare in conversation.

Well, that's not exactly right. Baldomare is quite the approachable mare, and she is willing to talk to anypony. Even if, most of the time, she will be the one doing most of the talking.

So, it is better to say that there are still some ponies who are capable of engaging with her in a conversation. And despite the obvious gap in expertise and knowledge, there are still ponies who can sit down with Baldomare and have something to say, without the exchange slowly turning into a lecture of sorts.

There is old Biedde, who has on occasion had lengthy conversations with her about… well, about fantasy books that they both read, apparently. But that they appeared to be discussing as vigorously as if it was actual history.

Firefly Breeze, a relatively young and innocent maid, is spoken of as one of the few ponies who can make Baldomare change her mind after she made a decision. And Rusty Nail, a farmhoof who has worked on the estate since before the Lady arrived, is said to have gotten into a messy disagreement with Baldomare about the effect of sunlight on crops.

Maddeningly, young Silky Stream has supposedly already outwitted Baldomare, precisely once, in a subject nopony seems to agree on. Some of the servants insist it was on a topic the filly must have studied about in school, while others reason it must have been about something like the result of a game of chance or a coin toss.

And then, of course, there is…



"[MOTH]?"

"No, no, it's not that either. Our summoner and the guest are separate ponies. But as I was saying, I shouldn't call her a new guest. I should call her an… acquisition."



And then, of course, there is fair Mareinette.

Fair Mareinette, who so often invites good Baldomare for a drink or three in her humble room within the wine cellar.

Fair Mareinette who, in her great charity, convinced the Lady to let some of the farmhoofs keep their jobs even after they lost a hoof or a leg. Who took them in, even, as their favored and "dedicated" servants.

Fair Mareinette, who is beloved by all in the estate, and who can do no wrong, and who would be delighted to have you in her company.

Yes, that Mareinette. It only makes sense that a mare as grand as she would be deemed interesting company to good Baldomare.

So, as it happened several times before, it just happens that the two mares are currently engaged in conversation, as they stroll around the great farmlands of the estate.



"But again, the more time I spend here, the more I see our summoner reflecting the habits of our time. Maybe it was inevitable? Or maybe these are just the timeless habits of those who dabble on the Lores? Who knows. There probably isn't a difference."

"[SECRET HISTORIES]?"

"Oh, you know exactly what I mean by that… but fine, I'll indulge you."



The two mares walk through the long roads of beaten dirt that stretch across the farmlands. The ones that are used by the farmhoofs to go here and there, carrying their carts and their tools, and the ones that serve as lines that divide the different harvests.

Every now and then they stop, to look at a group of farmers at work. Every now and then a group of farmers stop, to gaze at the fair mares as they pass by. One pale and shadowless like an intriguing mirage, the other large and regal like a black-clad Princess.

Still, their presence in the farmlands is as magical as it is mundane. Like a cool breeze on a sweaty brow, or the sight of a beautiful bird flying overhead. Their passage is something that is welcome, perhaps even celebrated, but also something that everypony understands is beyond them.

And so it also happens that their words, deep and mysterious as they may be, are also being lost in the wind and forgotten by the breeze.



"I once read that words, or perhaps language itself, are nothing but a convention. An agreed-upon way that we use to understand each other. After all, even though secrets are precious, the ability to understand one another is both useful and important. In fact, it is so important that the means we use to nurture that ability are far more diverse than just the use of language. It extends to culture, to habits, and several other things besides. Why, I daresay our desire to understand each other is one of the reasons why we both wear this pony-like form. Because we wouldn't be able to do much if the first words out of our mouth always had to be
be not afraid, no?"

"[HEART]."

"Sure, sure, semantics. The point that I'm trying to make is that our summoner… well, maybe she realizes it, or maybe she doesn't. But still, she stumbled upon a particular habit from our time."



The sun is still high in the sky. The irrigation-clouds that will be brought in near the end of the day are nowhere to be seen. And all around the two mare-things, everything is in peace.

Everything is where it should be. Everything is predictable. Everything is in its proper place.

Everything is under control.



"Because it is easy to ignore these conventions when you don't even know they are there. It is easy to let your legs guide you as you walk, and let your pace quicken or slow down as you please. But once you realize there is a tune? Once you realize there is actually a song on the background, that you have been dancing to all along? Well, once that happens you need to make a conscious effort to keep up with the pace."

"[LANTERN]."

"Exactly! After all, despite their disagreements, Lantern and Moth are still neighbors. And it is so easy to go from one to the other and… No, that's not right. It's easy to fall from Moth to Lantern. But there is no easy way back, once you do it."



All around them, farmhoofs and supervisors keep to their tasks as if it was natural. All around them, the world continues to spin as if that was the ordinary way of things.

An old farmer tips her straw hat at them while she pulls a cart, as she walks by the two pony-like creatures. A trio of farmers nervously consider approaching the two mares, for their advice or their blessings or just their presence, but fail to muster their courage before it is already too late. A group of foals, newcomers to the town, nervously gaze at them from their distant hiding spot, wondering if today was the day they would dare step a hoof into the property and trespass into the mysterious noblemare's land.

All around them, the world continues to spin as if everything that happens is utterly normal.

All around them, everypony continues living under the idea that everything around them is natural. And not that everything around them, from the seeds under the dirt to the clouds in the sky to the very sun and moon on the heavens, are not being moved by pony hoofs and pony will.



"It seems that our summoner realized that her life, or maybe everything, is a masquerade. It seems she finally realized that everything we do, from our habits to our thoughts to our very lives, are masks that we wear. That the very world, even, is nothing but the continuance of these conventions and habits and words that we jointly agree carry a particular meaning. And tonight, when she bring her new guest… when she brings back her latest acquisition, she will have taken an important step in accepting her place in all of this."

"[GRAIL]?"

"Oh, no. I wish that was the case, but it is much worse than that. Because she thinks of herself as a... the Hostess. And after tonight, after this latest decision of hers, our summoner will become obsessed with it. With keeping this masquerade running, with keeping this delightful party on rhythm with her music. With keeping the ignorant in ignorance, and the performers dancing. Of course, that is all well and good, and I think she will be a good host. After all, it was the hosts and hostesses of old that kept us all from killing each other back then, no? Somepony needs to keep the wheels spinning. And more importantly, somepony needs to keep everypony else from noticing there are wheels to begin with. Quite fitting, then, that she has the word covers on her name."



Mareinette stops, as she listens to those words. She stops, and she looks down at good Baldomare, and within the dark depth of her empty eye sockets she considers what the bright-mare just told her like a sommelier might consider a fine glass of wine.

She thinks, and she ponders, and good Baldomare inevitably begins to answer her unspoken question before it is even properly formed.



"I think you would approve of her, yes. I think this will be to your liking, in the end. Because just like the hosts and hostesses of our time, our summoner is not without her own habits and likings. In fact, I think you will come to the same conclusion when you see her. Our summoner does not care for her latest acquisition. At least, she doesn't care for her with the same fixation she does her family, and she will treat her like any other of her pawns. And yet, she made this decision all the same."

"…"


"Because this isn't about her latest acquisition. This isn't about the student herself. Oh no. This is about what she represented. Because the reflection of her acquisition, the one that will be whisked away by the snake in a few hours, was a failure. Worse than that, she was evidence of her failure. Living proof that our summoner couldn't protect somepony she took under her wings. She was… a crack on our summoner's mask. And that crack would only widen and grow, if left unattended, until it snapped her mask in half. And that simply wouldn't do for the Hostess of this masquerade, no? So… she did what every good hostess would do. She did what was necessary to continue the masquerade."



The wind stops blowing, as Baldomare says that. Not by design, and not due to any particular reason. This is, in truth, just a coincidence. Still, the wind stops blowing nonetheless, and the very world seems to hold its breath as Mareinette considers the implications of that.

She considers the implications of that… and how that might reframe her associate's previous actions… and how that might educate her decisions in the future… and also, and also…



Ah.

The wind begins to blow once again. Fiercer, this time, as if to make up for the short pause from a few moments ago.

The wind blows at Mareinette's regal cloak or red and black. And it pushes and presses against the nearby crops and fields. And it leaves Baldomare completely untouched and undisturbed as if the Lantern-Name was light itself.

The wind blows long and hard, and in its smooth gale it carries a new sound, that is now coming from the Grail-thing.



Clack-clack-clack-clack-clack-clack-clack-clack-clack-clack-clack-clack-clack



It should be impossible for a skull to smile. It should be impossible for a bone-dry corpse to feel mirth. It should be impossible for a thing that is oh so thirsty to feel sated.

And yet, if only for a moment, all of those things were happening.

Mareinette's delight makes itself known to the world, sounding at the same time like the laughter of a filly and the dissonant song of castanets.

And by the time the wind finally dies down, the two mares are gone. Both of them disappearing once they are satisfied with that conversation.





Mareinette is delighted by your recent decision, she has decided to reward you with
[REDACTED]

Well, there is no reason to delve too deep into what could have happened, or what you might have gained. After all, this is just a Was Not now. Right?

Right?

Move along now, dear.
Back to where you came from.
 
@OurLadyOfWires Weird, it went from a tie of 27 each to a difference of 2 when 1 vote was added to each, did i miss something?
If anyone finds a flaw in the vote counting, do let me know. There is still, barely, enough time for me to look into it and revert it.

But I don't think there were any issues, to be honest.

@OurLadyOfWires does this offer still hold?
Yes, the book-searching time-breaking option will be offered with this next vote period coming on the next update. That was my plan as well.

@OurLadyOfWires I just wanna say that having spent the last week or two reading the entire story, then rereading it more slowly to digest better, and going over pages and pages of old discussion I wanna say it's really impressive how well you were able to write all those nexus points where the direction of the story changed massively and make it all tie together with major plotlines and entire story-defining facts coming from unpredictable sources.
Thank you kindly! This really is motivating. I mean it!

Oh! Huh! Good idea! @OurLadyOfWires, any thoughts if this artefact would give Cadance a chance at learning the lores..?
I'm admittedly not too hot about giving Cadance Moth artifacts. I know that I was the one who said that maybe giving her one could hide her lores from Celly dearest. But teaching Cadance the Lores needs its own effort, and this is just too much of a sun-hot topic for me to want to delve into right now. Especially given how we are still in the middle of a turn, with other things going on.



Anyways, hope you are all doing well.

I wanted to write this omake because this is the canon "next update" that would have been written if Sci-Twi had won I like Mareinette. So now I can start writing your return to real life and open the vote for what comes next.

No prediction of when said update will drop. But it shouldn't take too long.



Also, unironic question, since WHEN does this site have a "open voting" option and a "new tally" button??? Did they import the SV tally system and didn't tell anyone??? I am genuinelly surprised, and this is a legitimate question that I just noticed.

Cheers,
 
Also, unironic question, since WHEN does this site have a "open voting" option and a "new tally" button??? Did they import the SV tally system and didn't tell anyone??? I am genuinelly surprised, and this is a legitimate question that I just noticed.
Wait WHAT?!

...it does?????
 
I swear it.

Also, in my "bb code enabled" vision, it says "voteresult 76". So it must be very, very new if this is the 76th vote this site tallied. So yeah, looks like a new feature.

Honestly? Nice!

Here, this is what I go:

Adhoc vote count started by OurLadyOfWires on Mar 6, 2025 at 9:41 PM, finished with 634 posts and 58 votes.


Also, again I also have the "open vote" button available for me when I post. Dunno if you guys have it as well or if its exclusive to the OP. But hey, that's new!
 
Also, again I also have the "open vote" button available for me when I post. Dunno if you guys have it as well or if its exclusive to the OP. But hey, that's new!
I don't see an open vote button (which is good), but I do see a shiny new "New Tally" button.

Convenient! I guess this means I can go delete NetTally off of my computer now.
 
Oh, the "What if we brought Twilight with us" story.

I will take the title as a hint we made the right choice. :V

"[FORGE]?"

"No, no, not that kind of guest. But you are right, in a sense. Or maybe you are coming from the right place? Well, it doesn't matter. Although I agree with you. Because maybe I shouldn't call that newcomer a guest…?"
QM mentioning the Forge Name.


[MOTH]?"

"No, no, it's not that either. Our summoner and the guest are separate ponies. But as I was saying, I shouldn't call her a new guest. I should call her an… acquisition."
Personal Moth Sacrament hint? Where we become another pony as the general effect? Makes sense with the whole self hate thing.
Edit: Wait, do we make a fake pony by making a mask or do we turn into them? Because Baldomare almost looked like she was saying others would see Velvet AND somepony else.

Fair Mareinette who, in her great charity, convinced the Lady to let some of the farmhoofs keep their jobs even after they lost a hoof or a leg. Who took them in, even, as their favored and "dedicated" servants.
Casual reminder that Mareinette has a budding cult she will consolidate the second she is free.

"[GRAIL]?"

"Oh, no. I wish that was the case, but it is much worse than that. Because she thinks of herself as a... the Hostess. And after tonight, after this latest decision of hers, our summoner will become obsessed with it. With keeping this masquerade running, with keeping this delightful party on rhythm with her music. With keeping the ignorant in ignorance, and the performers dancing. Of course, that is all well and good, and I think she will be a good host. After all, it was the hosts and hostesses of old that kept us all from killing each other back then, no? Somepony needs to keep the wheels spinning. And more importantly, somepony needs to keep everypony else from noticing there are wheels to begin with. Quite fitting, then, that she has the word covers on her name."
Okay we made the right choice indeed. The current Velvet already makes me uncomfortable and thinking she could get worse is just... disturbing. And also did Baldomare just say it would be worse than taking Mareinette's Sacrament? Holy fuck we dodged a bullet if that is true.

Mareinette is delighted by your recent decision, she has decided to reward you with [REDACTED]
Please tell me that wasn't enough of a change in her eyes to give us her Sacrament... That thought scares me.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top