Steelplaza
Custom Title
- Joined
- May 12, 2015
- Messages
- 253
- Likes received
- 1,262
I do appreciate when characters give the SI some push-back instead of just accepting his arguments. It makes it feel like a more honest debate.
It's kind of hard for me to say who is right given this is a weird comic book universe with conceptual entities and spirits of stasis and all of that. I don't think there's such thing as "evolution" of societies in the real world, but in the DC universe who knows?
If we want to make historical arguments, it's interesting to consider the case of Japan. When they were forced out of their isolationism by Admiral Perry and realized how far behind they were technologically and how much danger they were in of being reduced to a colonized state (as so many other countries in that region of the world were) they embarked on a campaign of deliberate modernization. They imported technology and studied it so they could build it themselves, and they sent out engineers to study in other countries and bring the knowledge back home.
I don't think it's necessary for the people of DC earth to invent all the technology for themselves. It's fine to crib from alien civilizations. If you live in India and are trying to import new power technology, does it matter if it was invented by a human in France or a Thanagarian across the galaxy? But the SI is probably correct in that people need to be able to learn how to build the technology themselves, even if they can't do it day one.
It's kind of hard for me to say who is right given this is a weird comic book universe with conceptual entities and spirits of stasis and all of that. I don't think there's such thing as "evolution" of societies in the real world, but in the DC universe who knows?
If we want to make historical arguments, it's interesting to consider the case of Japan. When they were forced out of their isolationism by Admiral Perry and realized how far behind they were technologically and how much danger they were in of being reduced to a colonized state (as so many other countries in that region of the world were) they embarked on a campaign of deliberate modernization. They imported technology and studied it so they could build it themselves, and they sent out engineers to study in other countries and bring the knowledge back home.
I don't think it's necessary for the people of DC earth to invent all the technology for themselves. It's fine to crib from alien civilizations. If you live in India and are trying to import new power technology, does it matter if it was invented by a human in France or a Thanagarian across the galaxy? But the SI is probably correct in that people need to be able to learn how to build the technology themselves, even if they can't do it day one.