LurkingInTheDeceit
“Brave” explorer treading “New” land
- Joined
- Feb 15, 2019
- Messages
- 3,063
- Likes received
- 11,366
Yeah I agree that Barty did his job if all his lessons were like the unforgivable lecture, I just don't think we saw any other lessons (although that could be applied to most of the classes I think, so extrapolating is fine). I don't know what spells, if any, he taught though (in a teach them to cast it way, not "this spell exists" way).Bardy Croutch in spite of being a literal enemy plant was the most competent defence against the dark arts teacher harry's year had, he actually did his job and taught them how to fight the dark arts and what they were. Unlike the other teachers who tip-toed around the subject. When his tenure ended all of his students where more capable of defending themselves which was his job.
we should remember his class wasn't about ethics or math or anything like that defence against the dark arts is a self-defence course at best and a military train program at worst.
EDIT:
Basically he showed them "This is what your enemy looks like, this is what it does and it's offensive capabilities, here is how to defend against it."
What else is a modern teacher expected to do?
Snape could: not bully the students, not show favouritism or prejudice, not attack the students, not try and frame the students, not help terrorists that want to kill the students (extenuating circumstances non withstanding), not try and scare/surprise the students while they're handling dangerous substances. They's probably more, but off the top of my head those are the reasons Snape was a bad teacher.